The man who caused history
Think of the history of the twentieth century and who is most responsible for it. You might be thinking of world leaders like Franklin Delano Roosevelt, Joseph Stalin, or Mao Zedong. Or perhaps you are thinking of those who invented the technology that changed the world, such as Albert Einstein or Tim Berners-Lee.
But I suggest a man you probably haven’t heard of named Gravilo Princip.
The day started off poorly for Archduke Franz Ferdinand when three security officials were left behind, by mistake. Then an assassin threw a bomb at his car! But the bomb bounced off his car and the assassination failed. The Archduke’s motorcade sped away to protect him from any other assassination attempts.
“The Ides of March have come and I am still alive!” – Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare
Princip’s realized he lost his chance, so he gave up and went to a nearby food shop. But when the motorcade started up again, someone forgot to tell the driver to change the route. When this was realized, the command was given to reverse, but the transmission was jammed so the car stopped right in front of Pincip.
By a ridiculous stroke of luck (or misfortune, depending on your point of view), between the security officials being left behind, the first failed assassination attempt, the driver not knowing the route, the transmission being jammed, Gravilo Princip shot and killed Archduke Ferdinand
Princip’s butterfly effect
As you might know, this assassination brings up long-standing tensions in Europe, setting off World War One.
As you might know, the treaty which ended World War One involved massive war reparations to be paid by the Germans. The German people came to resent of these foreign powers spread, making it possible for the Nazis to come to power. Thus begins World War Two.
As you might know, the victors of World War Two partitioned off Europe, and while they were doing so, certain tensions among the victors emerged. This led to the stand off of the Cold War.
So Princip brought about a series of events which caused the Cold War. Or perhaps the Archduke’s driver should be the one whom we say brought about these events. Or perhaps the man who owned the food shop that Princip stopped at, for if he were not there perhaps Princip would gone to a different place that wasn’t on the motorcade’s route.
Some would counterargue that the Austro-Hungarian empire was already ripe for conflict, and if not Princip, then someone else would set it off. But if it was set off in the middle east as a result of Ottoman aggression (there was unrest in the region ever since the Young Turk Revolution). Maybe the alignment would have been different. Russia would not feel compelled to defend the Slavic peoples, and maybe Russia uses this hypothetical war to seek a warm-water port, and with the manpower of Russia weighing on the other side of the scale, the outcome could be drastically different. The specific details of these events can matter a lot
We like to think that systems like human society have some predictable order. We like to think that this order is affected by world leaders and important people. We like to think that things happen for compelling reasons. But when a world war breaks out on account of the chauffeurs wrong turn, I realize that human society is so vastly complex and intricate that some events are just so ‘out there’ to be foreseen.
Forget Great Man History or Trends and Forces History, I propose Random History. Most events follow trends and forces or are influenced by great men; these may be somewhat predictable. But the events that really make a change, like 9/11, are completely random and unforeseen, even by scholars. That course of history wasn’t determined by simple rules ore logical reasons. It’s just Lady Fortuna spinning her wheel.
I think I’m going the way of Sartre.
- Part 2
- Scientific American: Gavrilo Princip, conspiracy theories and the fragility of cause and effect
- Chapter 1 of ‘The Black Swan’ by Nassim Taleb